Thousands of people are passionate about fudge from Mackinac Island. Our new poll proves it. Debate over who has the best fudge can get pretty serious. We've finally gotten to the bottom of it all.

The winner of The Best Fudge Shop on Mackinac Island is...

May's Candy!

May's Candy took first in our vote of all the fudge maker's on Mackinac Island.

May's Candy opened in Kansas in 1881. They made their way to Mackinac Island in the 1930s. One of their most memorable moments came on July 13, 1975 when President Gerald Ford paid them a visit. It's a pretty sweet resume.

Murdick's Fudge placed second and Joann's Fudge finished third.

Sound right to you?

If not, we invite you to take a fudge-tasting trip to Mackinac Island for quality control purposes.

Somebody's gotta do it.